Compostable packaging vs recyclable: what EU law actually requires
Compostable packaging, biodegradable packaging and recyclable packaging are three different things. Recyclable means the pack can be collected, sorted and turned into new material in a stream that exists today. Compostable means it breaks down under controlled composting conditions into compost, not into new material. Biodegradable, used on its own, carries no defined meaning: it does not say how long, in what environment, or with what left behind.
Two separate pieces of EU law govern this. Regulation (EU) 2025/40, the PPWR, decides which packaging must be compostable and which must be recyclable, and through Article 14 what may be claimed about those properties. Directive (EU) 2024/825 bans certain claims on the pack in all circumstances. This page covers both, along with what the certification standards prove and what composting plants report in practice.

12 Aug 2026
PPWR applies directly across the EU, Article 14 on claims included
27 Sep 2026
Generic environmental claims are banned in all circumstances
12 Feb 2028
Article 9: listed formats compostable, all other packaging designed for recycling
1 Jan 2030
Design-for-recycling grades decide market access
Compostable packaging, biodegradable and recyclable are not interchangeable
Recyclable describes a pack designed so that it can be collected, sorted and reprocessed into new material. For flexible packaging the practical route is mechanical recycling of single-polymer structures, PE with PE or PP with PP. The design rules are covered on the page about design for recycling.
Compostable describes a material that, under controlled composting conditions, breaks down into carbon dioxide, water and biomass within a defined period, without toxic residues and without degrading compost quality. Most compostable packaging needs the conditions of an industrial facility, not a garden heap.
Biodegradable means only that microorganisms can break the material down. With no standard attached, the word carries no timeframe, no environment and no guarantee about residues. Every compostable material is biodegradable; the reverse does not hold. From 27 September 2026, the word used on its own on a pack is a generic claim under Directive (EU) 2024/825.
What EN 13432 proves about compostable packaging
The European reference for industrial compostability of packaging is EN 13432. It requires at least 90% biodegradation within six months, at least 90% disintegration within twelve weeks under industrial composting conditions, and no toxic effects on the resulting compost. The equivalents are EN 14995 for non-packaging products, ASTM D6400 and ISO 17088.
Certification is a laboratory result, not a field result
Certification is obtained under controlled conditions and over durations that often exceed the real cycle of a composting plant. The published data diverges, and the decisive variable is the combination of polymer, thickness and plant residence time.
At an Austrian industrial plant, certified bags broke down within the first four weeks (Binner et al., Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2025). In a six-week industrial trial, thermoplastic starch bags exceeded 95% decomposition while PLA-based bags failed to reach the 90% threshold (Sikander et al., Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 2024).
A paired lab-and-plant study shows the gap most clearly. A flexible pack that left 0.3% residual mass after twelve weeks in the laboratory still retained 93.9% of its mass after three weeks in the actual plant, because the plant cycle was shorter than the certification test (Chong et al., Open Research Europe, 2022). A four-month full-scale windrow process achieved 98% mass loss with no adverse effect on compost quality (Gastaldi et al., Bioresource Technology, 2024).
Home compostable packaging is a separate certification
Home composting requires its own certification, such as OK compost HOME, because a garden heap never reaches industrial temperatures. In a UK citizen-science study across 1,648 households, 60% of items certified as home compostable did not fully disintegrate (Purkiss et al., The Big Compost Experiment, 2022). Certification is a necessary condition, not a promise that the pack disappears in every facility and every cycle.
Compostable packaging, recyclable and biodegradable side by side
| Criterion | Recyclable | Compostable | Biodegradable (uncertified) |
| End result | new material | compost | undefined |
| Correct destination | plastic recycling stream | industrial composting facility | undefined |
| Reference standard | design-for-recycling criteria, Article 6 grades | EN 13432, EN 14995, ASTM D6400, ISO 17088 | none implied |
| In the wrong stream | persists as a fragment in compost | contaminates the recyclate | unpredictable in both streams |
| PPWR position | general requirement, Article 6 | mandatory only for the formats in Article 9(1) | no standing as a compliance route |
| Claim on the pack | only above the PPWR minimum, with the scope stated (Article 14) | subject to Article 14, with the standard and conditions named | banned as a generic claim from 27 September 2026 |
The classification of a specific pack depends on its full structure and on the collection and treatment infrastructure in the market where it is sold.
Why compostable packaging contaminates the recycling stream
Compostable packaging and conventional plastics are not easily separated at automated sorting, because sorting lines were not built to distinguish them. A share of compostable packaging therefore ends up in the plastic stream, where it behaves as a contaminant and lowers the quality of the recyclate. The reverse failure also occurs: a conventional plastic that reaches a composting facility stays there as a fragment.
A pack is therefore designed for one route. For industrial flexible packaging, the route the legislation sets as the general requirement is recycling, through mono-material structures designed for recycling. Compostable fits where the product reaches organic waste together with its packaging.
When PPWR requires compostable packaging: Article 9 in three tiers
Recyclability is the general requirement of Article 6. From 1 January 2030, or 24 months after the delegated acts if later, packaging must meet the design-for-recycling grades to be placed on the EU market, as set out on the page about PPWR recyclability grades. Compostability is the exception, and Article 9 splits it into three tiers.
Mandatory across the EU
Article 9(1) requires industrial compostability by 12 February 2028 for two categories only. The first is the packaging defined in Article 3(1)(1)(f): permeable tea, coffee or other beverage bags and soft single-serve units that contain the beverage and are disposed of with it. The second is sticky labels affixed to fruit and vegetables. That is the entire mandatory list.
A national option, not an EU obligation
Article 9(2) lets a Member State that collects bio-waste separately and has the treatment infrastructure require compostability on its own territory for two further categories. They are non-permeable single-serve units intended for a machine, other than metal ones, defined in Article 3(1)(1)(g), and lightweight and very lightweight plastic carrier bags. Rigid coffee capsules sit here. Absent a national decision, they carry no compostability obligation.
Everything else, including biodegradable plastics
Article 9(3) closes the question for the rest of the market. By 12 February 2028, any packaging outside the first two tiers, including packaging made of biodegradable plastic polymers and other biodegradable materials, must be designed for material recycling in accordance with Article 6, without affecting the recyclability of other waste streams.
A biodegradable or compostable material does not exempt a pack from recyclability unless the format appears on the list in Article 9(1), or in a national measure under Article 9(2). For industrial flexible packaging, the compliance route is recyclability.
What may be printed on the pack
Two instruments govern the wording. Article 14 of the PPWR has applied since 12 August 2026. It admits claims about the properties the Regulation governs, compostability and recyclability among them, only above the applicable minimum requirements, with the scope of the claim stated.
Directive (EU) 2024/825 amends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, and its national measures apply from 27 September 2026. Among the practices it adds to the list banned in all circumstances, three bear directly on this subject.
Point 4a bans a generic environmental claim for which the trader cannot demonstrate recognised excellent environmental performance relevant to the claim. Recital 9 names the examples, and biodegradable is on that list, alongside eco-friendly, green, ecological, climate friendly and biobased. The Directive also observes that a claim such as biodegradable cannot be justified through the EU Ecolabel, because the Ecolabel criteria contain no biodegradability requirements for the products concerned.
Point 4b bans a claim about the entire product when it concerns only one aspect of it, such as recyclable printed on a pack where only the film qualifies and the closure or label does not. Point 10a bans presenting a requirement imposed by law on all products in the category as a distinctive feature of one offer.
The word biodegradable is not banned. Its generic use is. Under Article 2, point (p), of Directive 2005/29/EC, a claim whose specification is given in clear and prominent terms on the same medium is not generic. A statement naming the standard and the conditions, given on the pack, is a specific claim. The word alone is a generic one.
How the two instruments combine for recyclable, compostable, recycled-content and PFAS-free claims, and what happens to packaging already printed, is set out on the page on environmental claims on packaging under EmpCo and PPWR.
Neither the PPWR nor this Directive applies in Great Britain. A pack sold there falls under the CMA Green Claims Code instead.
The decision test: compostable packaging or recyclable
The starting question is which waste stream the pack reaches.
| Situation | Route | Basis |
| Permeable tea or coffee bag, soft single-serve unit | compostable | PPWR Article 9(1), by 12 February 2028 |
| Rigid coffee capsule for a machine | depends on each national market | PPWR Article 9(2), Member State option |
| Pack discarded with food waste by the consumer | compostable, where the local facility cycle matches the material | plant residence time against the certification test |
| Pack enters household or commercial plastic collection | recyclable mono-material | PPWR Articles 6 and 9(3) |
| Biodegradable printed on the pack | specified on the pack, or removed | Directive 2005/29/EC, Annex I, point 4a, from 27 September 2026 |
Where the answer is recyclable, the work is structural: moving the pack to a single-polymer design that a sorting line can read and a recycler can process. That programme is set out on the page about the transition to mono-material packaging, and the barrier trade-off it forces on the page comparing metallised film and EVOH.
Frequently asked questions
Is compostable packaging recyclable too?
No, and it should not enter the recycling stream. Compostable packaging behaves as a contaminant in mechanical plastic recycling and lowers the quality of the recyclate. A pack is designed for one route or the other.
Is compostable packaging the same as biodegradable?
No. Compostable is defined by standards such as EN 13432, with a stated timeframe, stated conditions and a requirement to leave no toxic residue. Biodegradable, used alone, has no implied standard and says nothing about how long or in what environment. Every compostable material is biodegradable; the reverse does not follow.
Will compostable packaging break down in a garden compost heap?
Usually not. Most compostable packaging is certified for industrial composting, which runs hotter than a garden heap. Home composting requires a separate certification such as OK compost HOME, and even then a UK study across 1,648 households found that 60% of items certified as home compostable did not fully disintegrate.
Do coffee capsules have to be compostable under the PPWR?
Not through a direct EU obligation. A non-permeable capsule intended for a machine falls under Article 9(2), which allows each Member State to require compostability on its territory where separate bio-waste collection and treatment infrastructure exist. The EU-wide mandatory list covers only permeable tea and coffee bags, soft single-serve units and sticky fruit and vegetable labels, from 12 February 2028.
Does biodegradable plastic satisfy the PPWR?
No, not by virtue of being biodegradable. Article 9(3) requires that by 12 February 2028 all packaging outside the compostability lists, expressly including packaging made from biodegradable plastic polymers, must be designed for material recycling under Article 6. The material choice does not replace the recyclability requirement.
Can we still print biodegradable on our packaging?
From 27 September 2026, not as a standalone claim. Directive (EU) 2024/825 bans a generic environmental claim without demonstrable recognised excellent environmental performance, and recital 9 names biodegradable among the examples. A statement that names the standard and the conditions, given clearly and prominently on the pack, is not a generic claim. The word is not prohibited; its unspecified use is.
Sources
Regulation (EU) 2025/40, as published in the Official Journal L of 22 January 2025: Article 3(1), point (1)(f) and (g), Articles 6, 9 and 14. Directive (EU) 2024/825: recital 9, and the definition in Article 2, point (p), and points 4a, 4b and 10a of Annex I that it inserts into Directive 2005/29/EC. EN 13432 for industrial compostability of packaging.
Field data: Binner et al., Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 2025; Sikander et al., Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 2024; Chong et al., Open Research Europe, 2022; Gastaldi et al., Bioresource Technology, 2024; Purkiss et al., The Big Compost Experiment, 2022.
Related resources
Compostable or recyclable is decided by the waste stream, not by the label.
Questions about the documentation for the structures we supply.
Reviewed by Laura Ionescu, VLM Poliplast SRL, on 14.11.2026, against the official texts listed under Sources. VLM Poliplast SRL holds editorial responsibility for the content of this page. This page is not legal advice.